The Eda Charedis is imploding

Hat tip to Dovid, reports coming to hand indicate that there have been a series of arrests at 4:30am in Meah Shearim involving the Shamash of the Av Beis Din, R’ Tuvia Weiss. After a long investigation, it would seem that there has been a massive money laundering operation happening through the offices of the Shamash, Amram Shapira. Also arrested were Shmuel Lubatzki who ran the “charity” known as HaVaad HaArtzi as well as Yossele Sheinberger and Ya’acov Eisenbach. The charges are serious and involve many millions. Through their representative, Yitzchak Shlomo Blau, the Eda have sent a message to the Israeli police that all bets are off, and communication lines are now closed.

I expect that there will be a new ferocious round of violence, tyre and rubbish burning and mass demonstrations. Worse, our friends at Satmar, who are philosophically aligned with the Eda, have suggested that Chassidim demonstrate in the USA against the “religious persecution” of minorities. Will they demonstrate in Australia too?

In the meanwhile, one of the two Satmar Rebbes, R’ Zalman Leib?, has condemned the Belzer Rebbe because the latter dared to suggest that violence may not be the way to deal with the issues being faced. In a rambling tirade, lacking  Torah sources or halachic veracity, the Satmar Rebbe basically said that you can’t fight a lack of kedusha (read Tumah) by adding Kedusha elsewhere. He suggested that one had to “confront” the Tumah. He’s right, but he hasn’t explained why confronting can’t be achieved by increasing Kedusha. He seems to think that Kedusha can’t permeate. We know that is simply wrong! We live in times where the most powerful method to deal with the opposite of kedusha is to bring kedusha to it! You can’t mandate Kedusha through fiat. That’s a medieval approach, at best. It doesn’t work in the free world. Period.

Next time you consider Satmar, remember that although they do great things in Chesed, they are aligned with the Eda Charedis in no uncertain fashion.They are implacably against Israel and their world view is one that is increasingly aggressive against anyone who doesn’t allow their spreading tentacles to transform and supplant an existing landscape with their definitions of Tzniyus etc. It’s in our midst too. Today, in East St. Kilda, as I got out of my car, 3 little boys from the Adass offshoot school said “look the Tziyoni is here” after which they quickly scuttled back up their drive way. Who is teaching these kids such disgraceful hate laden invective? Am I also the Tumah that the Satmar Rebbe and the Eda Charedis wants to “attack”? Are the women wearing Sheytels and Tichels and little girls going to School in Bet Shemesh, the Kochos HaTumah?

We are in big trouble. These extremists have gone way too far. The market needs a correction.

Author: pitputim

I've enjoyed being a computer science professor in Melbourne, Australia, as well as band leader/singer for the Schnapps Band. My high schooling was in Chabad and I continued at Yeshivat Kerem B'Yavneh in Israel and later in life at Machon L'Hora'ah, Yeshivas Halichos Olam.

2 thoughts on “The Eda Charedis is imploding”

  1. As I said in an earlier thread about the Badatz Edah Haredit hechsher, I agree with your views on religious extremism, but I would be cautious about this news item. When there are large-scale arrests coming in the wake of a media hysteria, I would maintain a skeptical view about what is going on. Frankly, I have little faith in the police investigators and the state prosecution….there are highly politicized and, frankly, anti-religious, anti-YESHA settler and anti-Right politically. Just recently they arrested 5 fellows from YESHA for supposedly conducting “espionage” against the IDF regarding IDF plans to destroy outposts in YESHA. Big media blast about it, but as I understand, they were all released from custody.
    Another example are the multi trials against Ehud Olmert (whom I despise, particularly for his giving orders to beat up young kids at Amona). In each case, several people were indicted along with him, but the cases do not seem strong. The latest is the “Holyland” bribery case in which they also indicted the former mayor of Jerusalem. I will go out on a limb an predict most if not all charges will end up being dropped.
    So I would say the same about this case regarding the Edah. A lot of people were arrested. coming in the wake of the media hysteria about Haredim. Again, I will say they will not be convicted of anything in the end, even if they are charged.
    All of this is a product of the sick legal system in Israel which is hyperpoliticized. A final note to remember: ALL PROSECUTIONS OF PUBLIC FIGURES ARE POLITICAL VENDETTAS, not a search for “justic”. This does not mean they are necessarily innocent, but it is a matter of the police and state prosecutors saying: GET SOMETHING ON HIM! Katzav is simply one more victim of this system.


  2. Satmar and those in their orbit maybe not consider people who are not committed to the Halachic process as Jews.
    Their anti Zionist position is but one of their theologically positions which demarcates them from the rest of the Klal.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: